Infection Control

IC Salary Survey

Lone ICPs face
multiple challenges

Salaries break $60,000 as responsibilities escalate

by Jeannie Akridge

Hospital infection control practitioners often times feel like Atlas, hoisting the weight of the world on their shoulders, which for each one is the burdensome task of ensuring quality outcomes against enemies unseen by the naked eye.

ICPs are among the hospital’s first line of defense against an arsenal of threats to the safety and well-being of patients and workers, as well as to bottom line profits. ICPs collect data and track infections, spearhead preparedness plans, and educate hospital employees on best practices – to name just a few critical tasks.

Salaries for these indispensable employees reached $60,000 for the first time this year, according to Healthcare Purchasing News’ 2006 Infection Control Salary Survey. While this figure represents a 6 percent increase over the average 2005 ICP salary, many would argue that ICPs are worth their weight in gold when it comes to protecting the integrity of the hospital, saving lives and adverting costly risks.

A recent analysis by the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council (PHC4) examined the effects of the state’s hospital-acquired infections during 2004. Starting in 2004, Pennsylvania hospitals were required to submit data on four types of hospital-acquired infections to PHC4.

As if unnecessary deaths and extra hospital days weren’t enough, the PHC4 analysis showed that the financial toll of the 11,668 hospital-acquired infections reported in 2004 amounted to additional total payments of $614 million for the state. The analysis also found that the average hospital payment for a patient with an infection was 7 times higher than for a patient without a hospital-acquired infection – $60,678 vs. $8,078.

A Washington Post article that reported on the PHC4 findings1 noted that while hospitals bill more for such cases, profits can easily dwindle to nothing. As an example, The Post cited a Pennsylvania hospital chief of medicine who found that of the 54 cases his staff handled involving a central line, the average payment was $64,894, yet the average costs were $91,733 – a real blow to the hospital’s bottom line.

The ICP’s value to the hospital and even to the community cannot be overstated. Yet, amazingly, the position still lacks crucial support and resources from top management at many facilities.

"I think one of the challenges that ICPs still have in the hospitals is getting the support from the management staff," said Linda Spaulding, founder and CEO, InCo and Associates LLC, an international infection control consulting firm based in Lakewood Ranch, FL. "Some hospitals will have 500 beds and one ICP. This kind of staffing makes it very difficult to develop and run a strong infection control program. You have to be extremely creative," said Spaulding. "With the emergence of new drug resistant organisms, with changes in guidelines and regulations for infection control, it is difficult for one ICP in a large hospital setting to keep up with all the work. Don’t get me wrong; some large hospitals do have more than one ICP, but there are still many out there that have not staffed this position correctly."

The ICP profile
The average respondent to HPN’s 2006 Infection Control Salary Survey is a 50-year-old female Registered Nurse with a bachelor’s degree who goes by the title of Infection Control Coordinator. She has worked in infection control an average of 10 years, and at her current facility for an average of 8 years. She works in a stand-alone, non-profit, rural 189-bed hospital and the department she works in has between 1 and 5 employees.

While undoubtedly the majority of hospital infection control professionals are female, males made up an additional one percent of our respondents this year to comprise 6 percent of the total. And for the first time this year, salaries for women working in infection control topped men’s salaries by about $200 per year.

Experience and title
When comparing years of experience in infection control to the number of years spent on the job at the ICP’s current facility, we found that years in the profession was a more predictable determining factor for salaries. Those working more than 25 years in infection control (9 percent of our respondents) rated the highest salaries at $68,181, while those just starting out in the profession, with less than two years of experience, earned an average salary of $56,413. It should be noted that salaries for these rookie ICPs jumped more than12 percent over 2005.

Those earning the most for their tenure at a particular facility have worked in the same place between 15 and 19 years, and they earned on average $63,875. Those ICPs just coming on board at their facility, with less than two years of experience, earned $59,537, nearly $500 more per year than those with a 20-24 year tenure at their facility.

Highest earners by age were those ICPs between 56 and 60 years old, with an average reported salary of $65,233. Almost 10 percent of our respondents were over the age of 60; and two respondents were over 70 years old.

While the infection control nurse continues to be the lowest paid of the ICPs, averaging $54,628 a year, her salary is not far behind that of the IC Coordinator at $58,877. The IC Director is the highest paid, with an average salary that jumped nearly 14 percent over last year, to reach $66,802. IC Managers commanded the second highest salaries, jumping more than 17 percent over last year for an average of $65,882.

Facility stats
When it comes to salaries and hospital size, bigger is better. Not surprisingly, those working in hospitals with more beds, make more money. Our 2006 survey results topped out at $72,500 for facilities with 750 or more beds, while those working in a facility with up to 99 beds, earned a more modest $54,327.

The size of the facility, however, does not determine the number of infection control employees. More than 97 percent of respondents said their facility had between one and five employees, and this had no correlation to the number of beds in the hospital. ICPs who worked in hospitals with anywhere from 0-1000 beds all reported that their facility had just 1 to 5 employees. One ICP at a 200-299 bed hospital said her department had more than 30 employees, but that was the one exception. Less than 3 percent of respondents said their facility had six or more employees, even at facilities with 750-999 beds.

This year, ICPs working in suburban facilities (31 percent of respondents) were the highest paid at $66,000. While the largest percentage of our respondents (42 percent) work for rural facilities, they were the lowest earners at $53,255.

We also found that government-owned facilities paid their ICPs considerably more than their nonprofit or for profit counterparts. Salaries for those at government-owned facilities reached $69,400; non-profit facilities paid $60,233 (66 percent of respondents) and for profit facilities, $57,500.

As in previous years, about 70 percent of our survey respondents work for a stand-alone hospital, and their salaries were about 6 percent higher than last year at $58,965. Another 23 percent work for an Integrated Delivery Network (IDN) or Multi-Group practice, and these respondents earned on average $63,450. The 7 percent of our respondents who worked for a long-term care or home health facility earned an average salary of $66,470.

Regionally speaking, one-third of our respondents are located in the Central U.S., while another third reside in the Northeast region. Once again, those working in the Central region were the lowest paid at $55,259. Highest earners continue to work in the Pacific region at an average salary of $67,955. This year, the Northeast region experienced the highest salary jump, from $57,500 in 2005 to $65,675 in 2006.

More than a third of our salary survey respondents said they reported directly to either the Director/Manager of Nursing and/or the Chief Nursing Officer at their facility, while another third report to the Director of Quality/ Risk Management. New to our survey this year is the category of Chief Medical Officer, which was selected by 6 percent of respondents.

Education, education, education
"Education is the key component of infection control," emphasized Spaulding. And our survey results confirm that, indeed, education is indispensable for the ICP.

Nearly a quarter of our 2006 IC Salary Survey respondents hold a post-graduate degree, and they earn on average $68,056. Forty-five percent of respondents hold a bachelor’s degree and they earned on average $59,935.

Certification is also vital to the ICP position: Of the 65 percent of our respondents who reported that they were certified, the most common certification was from the Certification Board of Infection Control and Epidemiology (CBIC).

When it comes to licenses, nearly 80 percent of our respondents are certified as a Registered Nurse and 9 percent as a medical technologist.

Responsibilities
The average amount of work time our ICPs spent on infection control was 75 percent, though 37 percent of our respondents said they spend 100 percent of their time on infection control issues. Other duties performed by ICPs include: employee health (45 percent), education (24 percent), patient safety (15 percent), quality performance management (15 percent), utilization management (8 percent), and risk management (7 percent). Thirty percent of respondents reported "other" duties which included everything from coordinating bariatric programs, to bioterrorism response, discharge planning, environment of care safety, nursing administration, workers compensation, and wound care.

Certainly, the ICP wears many hats that may or may not relate directly to infection control, and no doubt it’s a lot for a single ICP to handle alone.

"If you think of how much teaching that an ICP [must do] at a hospital that’s 300 beds and she’s the only ICP collecting data on all of the patients that are admitted, all of the surgery cases that are done, all of the community acquired infections, how much time is left over for education? The resources have never really been there for the department to be super strong" said Spaulding.

When asked what they would like to see more coverage of in HPN, top answers from our responding ICPs included: nosocomial infections/prevention (78 percent); mandatory reporting of infections (67 percent); prevention of surgical site infections (58%); and bioterrorism preparedness (49 percent).

While only 38 percent of respondents said that their facility has stockpiled supplies to prepare for a possible flu pandemic, it’s definitely a topic of discussion among ICPs.

"ICPs are spearheading committees in some of the hospitals; they’re getting the talk going," said Spaulding of the ICP’s involvement in flu pandemic preparedness.

"There are a lot of policies and procedures going into place, a lot of talk, a lot of staff education going on," Spaulding continued. "A lot of the health departments are trying to pull together hospitals and have meetings to discuss, ‘what would we do if a pandemic happened?’ In the hospitals, some are able to set up plans, and some aren’t. Some people take it serious. They know that this could be the worst thing that our generation has ever faced should it actually turn into a pandemic. And then you have the other side of the coin, where they say, ‘it’s never going to happen, we’re not going to pay attention to it.’ So you have both of those groups in the same hospital. How do you convince them, even though it might not happen we should still have an idea of what we would do if it did happen?"

"When everybody is going to take it real serious is when the birds that are on their way to Alaska that they think may be infected with the avian influenza – when they land there and the news media says the United States now has avian influenza, you’ll see people take that concern up a level. You’ll see very rapid response by hospitals to take it more serious and prepare much quicker. So I think what ICPs are doing now, they’re starting the conversations, they’re making people aware that it’s there. And I think they’ll get a lot of help when the news media says the birds have landed."

Spaulding challenges ICPs to take the initiative to bring preparedness plans to fruition, and to encourage their hospital to participate in tracking programs set up by their state’s department of health.

"Many state departments of health are putting together programs so that when patients come into the emergency room with infections, it’s automatically put into a database, and sent off to the department of health. The department of health keeps track of the emergency room, as far as what they’re starting to see. So if we’re going to have an outbreak of something in a community, we have a better tracking system, we pick it up quicker.

"One of the hospitals that I was at recently opted not to buy into that program," said Spaulding. "They don’t want to do it, because it will take up too much of the staff’s time. Well, if you’re the first hospital to see the avian influenza, and a lot of your people get sick and possibly die, then you have no room to complain because you’re the one that opted not to do it. It should be the hospital that says, ‘yes, we’re going to do it.’"

Just the reverse of pandemic preparedness, 65 percent of our respondents said their facility is preparing procedures for mandatory reporting of infections.

"I think every hospital needs to take it serious," said Spaulding of the need to prepare for mandatory reporting of infections whether the ICP’s state has already instated laws to do so. "They need to look at what they’re doing for infection control. They need to make sure that they have good criteria for determining infections. Because ultimately, I don’t think we’re going to stop this from happening."

"And hospitals need to start preparing now," continued Spaulding. "But I don’t see a lot of emphasis on hospital management going to infection control and saying ‘OK, what criteria are we using? Are we tightening things up? Do we know that the rates we’re reporting are 100 percent accurate? Do we know what we’re comparing it against?’ They’re more or less saying, ‘infection control’s going to take care of it.’

"When the law gets passed, that’s when it will be important to them. The first time that the rates are published, they’re going to go back to the ICP, and say ‘you have to get our rates down, why are rates high?’ That’s kind of late in the game. But a lot of things that you look at from an infection control standpoint are reactive versus proactive. A lot of ICPs try to be proactive, but we can’t show that we’re saving a lot of money, always, just because of the nature of the job. Yet if we don’t do the education, if we don’t have the resources, we can’t train the staff to decrease the infections."

A bit of good news for ICPs, 10 percent more respondents than last year reported a salary increase over their previous year’s base salary, for a total of 75 percent receiving an increase that averages 3.8 percent of their base pay. Likewise, 75 percent of respondents expected to receive a bonus as part of their 2006 compensation. Also on an upward trend, 57 percent of our ICPs said they felt very secure in their current position, up from 51 percent last year.

Perhaps the day is approaching when ICPs will receive the resources and support from management that’s been long overdue. HPN

References:

1. "Infections Take Heavy Toll on Patients, Profit, Hospitals Urged to Boost Prevention" By Ceci Connolly, Washington Post Staff Writer, Wednesday, March 29, 2006.

May
2006