Doing more with less: Redefining inventory organization
Processes, products integrate to drive information access
by Rick Dana Barlow
|
Medical Design Systems MX4400D |
L ike clockwork, the daily delivery
of just-in-time stock arrives at the hospital dock. Check.
Supply chain management staff members break the bulk for
internal distribution to end user locations. Check.
With sighs of resignation, they then move the inventory
clusters to a variety of clinical storerooms and closets, ready to shoehorn
as much as they can into the jam-packed areas. Check.
But it doesn’t have to be this way.
Simply put, organizing supplies and equipment within a
facility’s confines remains a hallmark of effective supply chain management.
But limited space, coupled with supply and equipment hoarding, present a
recipe for cluttered minefields of products, absent a burst of
organizational creativity.
So how can healthcare facilities redesign and improve
inventory locations using new products and systems in the market today, as
well as simple ingenuity? To prevent stockouts, error-prone inventory
levels, expired supplies and a basic inability to locate needed products,
what strategies make the most sense for organizing and storing supplies and
equipment within a facility for more effective supply chain management?
Those strategies may involve exploring recent and near-future developments
in storage system applications and capabilities that will contribute to
performance improvement, in addition to smart planning.
Healthcare Purchasing News caught up with several
executives from storage system manufacturers to get their input and insights
on the processes and products that can make a difference.
High tech or high touch?
If you’re looking for a universal storage-system-in-a-box to
solve common problems a la the consumer market, you’ll be searching a long
time.
But that doesn’t mean simple solutions aren’t available.
"There seem to be lots of high-tech solutions being talked
about with [radiofrequency identification], ‘smart cabinets,’ etc.," said
Patricia List, executive vice president,
Medical Design Systems, Lenexa, KS.
"Some of those solutions of the future will no doubt work well in some
environments; some won’t. There is no one solution to medical storage. There
are too many variables – including personnel compliance, numbers of
procedures, PAR levels. Cost is always a big factor, and many facilities
just can’t justify spending hundreds of thousands to replace storage
systems.
|
IRSG’s High Density Overhead Storage |
"We believe there is a real need to just simply design
storage for each department in clean, closed units that are well organized,
so the available space is fully utilized. Most customers are surprised to
find how much space was actually being wasted and is freed up after we
reorganize their storage."
Nick Klusty, vice president, Western region,
Logiquip LLC,
Galesburg, MI, emphasized the desired payback for supporting more advanced
inventory management processes, such as just-in-time management with
low-unit-of-measure items.
"We see hospitals going in two directions," Klusty said.
"Since non-chargeable, low-cost items are growing in percentage in any given
supply area, some facilities are not seeing the ROI for high-ticket
inventory management systems. Many facilities are going back to simple
inventory management procedures. With this they still need the capacity in
the storage areas. This is getting more important because in order for a
facility to move more towards just-in-time inventory practices they need
increased capacity on the nursing units. Central supply areas are becoming
smaller and smaller as more facilities increase the percentage of items that
skip that area and go right from the truck to the nursing units."
Klusty also expressed some hesitation, if not trepidation,
about RFID as an option.
"RFID is still being discussed for inventory tracking and
management," he noted. "However, many material management supplies for
nursing units are low dollar and don’t justify the cost of the technology.
We are still waiting to see where this technology is headed in regards to
these supply items."When it comes to using technology to increase
efficiencies and decrease costs, however, integration between existing and
new technologies is the critical factor, according to Scott Bostick, vice
president and general manager,
Pyxis Supply Technologies, Cardinal Health
Inc. "Vendors will be expected to provide integration with existing
information systems to extend the hospital’s clinical information
infrastructure," he noted. "Automation of processes that currently require
manual data entry allows clinicians more time to focus on patient care and
reducing error rates."
|
InnerSpace System 100 |
But Bostick also predicted that storage system vendors
increasingly will shift away from simply selling product and toward selling
"solutions" where they work with customers "to optimize material management
practices and minimize overall costs to the hospitals," he said. "Over time
it is expected that the development in storage systems will become less
about the physical hardware but rather the services and the overall
partnerships that manufacturers can provide their customers."
Efficiency in the supply chain shouldn’t be dismissed, Joe
Dattilo, president,
PAR Excellence Systems Inc., Cincinnati, emphasized.
"Patient care is improved whenever the supply chain can be made more
efficient," he added, such as when "human error is removed from the
replenishment identification process."
InnerSpace (Grand Rapids, MI) recently introduced the System
100 which uses embedded RFID technology and biometric security access to
reliably and accurately track and account for high cost clinical supplies in
real time without the need for manual processes. System 100 can assist
hospitals in maximizing charge capture by ensuring user compliance and
accountability. Because it interfaces with hospitals’ business systems it
helps streamline processes and reduce errors.
Omnicell Inc.
(Mountain View, CA) introduced its OptiFlex SS
9.0 supply chain management system earlier this year. A complete preference
card-driven system that tracks supplies, special items and other aspects of
surgical service cases, the OptiFlex SS 9.0 system delivers important new
features in an integrated solution that includes management of both secure
cabinets and open shelves. Surgical services managers and nurses now have
the ability to efficiently handle supplies in multiple operating departments
across hospital environments and provide an increased level of secure
storage for IV solutions.
The OptiFlex SS preference list system creates a unique bar
code for each surgical case based on the physician, the procedure and the
patient. Real-time case management allows dynamic adjustment of the supplies
issued during the procedure. In addition, the system tracks all required
time segments for reporting, data analysis and charging purposes.
Product vs. process
Oftentimes, improved processes can be the natural outcome of
new products – or at least different ones.
|
PAR Excellence's PAR Bins |
For example, PAR Excellence developed its PAR Bins automated
replenishment system that uses weight sensors and automatically sends a
replenishment order to materials management whenever the bin/item reaches a
reorder level. "No human intervention is required," Dattilo said. "PAR Bins
do not require input
or action by the caregivers or the materials staff. Installation is quick
and simple. A small plastic sensor module is simply placed between the
louver and the bin."
Meanwhile, Logiquip has moved in the opposite direction.
"Our No. 1 focus is to get materials managers away from
plastic bins," Klusty said. "Plastic bins can be moved and lost, causing
stockouts and difficulty in the assessment part of inventory management. Our
products are all open wire, and with our divider system, products have their
own dedicated space that does not move. Instead of ‘shoe-horning’ supplies
into little plastic bins, with our Par Wall and Par Stor systems they can
move dividers to create the perfect amount of space needed for any
particular supply. The addition of fine mesh wire baskets allows a facility
to eliminate the need for plastic bins altogether."
Klusty stressed the simplicity of the company’s new LH3
hanging label holders. They come in five colors so that "facilities can
color code by expiration date, lead time, supply type, making it much
quicker to identify fast moving items and keep ahead of potential stockout
issues," he added.
|
LogiQuip Par Wall |
Medical Design Systems started promoting its foray into
steel earlier this year with its MASS Metal line of powder-coated steel
cabinets and carts in addition to its standard melamine models.
The metal products are often preferable for supply storage
in the operating room environment, according to List, because they are
lighter, which is essential for large carts that are moved a lot. They
feature modular interior components that slide in and out on ABS side
panels, making them very easy to reconfigure anytime packaging changes, she
indicated, and "they can be totally redesigned in a matter of minutes if
they need to be repurposed for different supplies or procedures."
Modu-Stor is a unique new high density storage system from
San Clemente, CA-based Distribution Systems International Inc. (DSI),
designed for use in the OR, Central Supply, Emergency Room and Med Surg
Nursing floors. The company maintains it can increase storage space in a
given area by 30 percent to 60 percent depending on the products being
stored. The flexible system features a variety of open and enclosed
configurations and bin sizes. The standard divider systems are unique in
that each bin configuration can be customized to the particular end-users
requirements.
DSI offers free CAD drawings provided by an in-house
engineer in an electronic format for jobs as small as closets, to room
renovations to new building construction. DSI representatives provide
product assembly and installation when requested. The products are
manufactured in Southern California and DSI maintains ample inventory on the
product to allow for next day shipment if required. Cabinets are also
available with tempered glass doors and key-less entry systems, floor or
wall mounted.
The new V-Series line of high density, heavy-duty cabinets,
carts and workstations from InnerSpace allow for more storage in less space
due to partitioned, full-extension drawers. All items are within easy reach
and in full view which translates to fast, effortless retrieval. Movable
interlocking steel partitions and dividers are shipped fully assembled and
allow drawer compartment sizes to be adjusted to accommodate supplies of
varying sizes and shapes. Roll-out shelves are also available for storing
instrument trays and other large bulky items.
|
DSI Modu-Stor |
John Waner, now former CEO of
IRSG, Woodinville, WA,
contended that packaging and assembly remain key selling points.
"One of the frustrations of ordering storage equipment is it
arrives unassembled, thus sitting in the warehouse until staff is available
to assemble it," said Waner, who retired from the company on October 1.
"This, along with incorrect assembly, results in departments continuing to
work with their current storage issues and the solution being unavailable
and unusable as soon as it arrives. Using a company that offers the option
of receiving their shelving units factory-assembled stream lines the
reorganization process. With IRSG’s ‘ship assembled’ program, customers can
simply unwrap the shelving and put it to use, thus saving time, frustration
and expense.
"Seamless integration between systems and one-touch
accessibility to information are driving efficiencies and redefining storage
system development, according to Bostick. He noted that the Pyxis
ProcedureStation easily can be linked to the hospital’s Operating Room
Information System (ORIS), enabling "clinicians to chart charge and reorder
supplies with just the touch of a button; streamlining inventory, improving
workflow and providing clinicians with more time to focus on patient care."
The company’s new hosted intelligence tool, the Supply
Performance Dashboard, provides hospitals with more "visibility to supply
chain and point of use performance along with the opportunity to quickly
identify problem areas and necessary improvements," he added.
But nothing beats the bins when it comes to cost-conscious
and justifiable efficiency tools, Dattilo argued. A typical PAR location of
200 items can be installed for approximately $1,000, offering caregivers and
materials management staff an organized but flexible methodology to
immediately locate, dispense and replenish supplies, he said, one that’s
complementary to a point-of-use system.
Chipping
away at endoscope storage challenges, theft
Leverage RFID technology leveraged to improve usage, reprocessing &
storage
by Bryan Christianson
As the growth of endoscopic procedures continues in response to
market demographic trends and the advent of additional procedural
techniques and approaches, healthcare organizations are continuing to
invest in innovative endoscope technology that will allow them to meet
this growing demand.
With many organizations spending over $1 million in equipment to be
used in settings ranging from gastroenterological endoscopy suites to
integrated operating rooms, too often the focus on that investment is
confined to its utilization within the procedure room. In turn, a focus
on maximizing the value from the investment in those assets goes
overlooked and little emphasis is placed on what occurs outside of the
procedure room.
For example, information regularly appears in media channels and
trade publications highlighting instances of theft of flexible
endoscopes that are taken from the patient care setting. Sadly, for some
organizations the value of stolen equipment has reached levels of
$300,000 or more. It’s somewhat understandable how this can occur given
there can be a high number of endoscopes that need to be placed in an
accessible location set in the middle of a hectic, fast-paced procedural
area. However, in determining this to be the ideal location for storing
the equipment, the decisions to place the equipment in an easily
accessible, unsecured setting invites the possibility of theft.
Similarly, another issue identified outside the four walls of the
procedure room is the importance of maintaining compliance with
endoscope reprocessing protocols. With the risk of creating instances of
cross-contamination of equipment and using equipment that could lead to
potential patient infections, there is a high level of emphasis to be
placed on completing the high-level disinfection (HLD) of the
endoscopes. As more and more procedural areas focus on maximizing the
volume of cases to be completed during the day, the pressures to turn
around equipment throughout the day only intensify. However, with this
pressure for quick turnarounds the potential for error and rushed
judgment also intensifies.
To address these two significant issues with endoscope storage and
utilization management, along with several others, most care providers
have found constraints and limitations when using common manually based
approaches. With the increasing case volumes and a limited amount of
staff time to support manual processes, solving these challenging
operational issues requires a solution beyond the traditional methods.
With this in mind, Mobile Aspects introduced a product that addresses
these challenges through using radio frequency identification (RFID)
technology.
The product combines storage hardware, RFID technology and software
functionality that is deployed through cabinet-based storage units and
freestanding work stations. Each endoscope located within a
cabinet-based storage device is affixed with an RFID tag. To open and
access the storage unit, the user logs in by scanning an employee
identification badge or other authentication device. Upon log in, the
user selects the appropriate patient from a touch screen monitor. Once
the patient is identified, the cabinet unlocks and the user simply
removes the scope from the cabinet, closes the door and moves onto the
procedure room. As a powerful by-product of this simple process
automation, the system tracks the individual who removed the endoscope
from the unit. In addition, the endoscope is automatically associated
for use with the patient identified and a detailed record of scope
utilization is automatically created, including specific data such as
equipment vendor, model type, serial number and other key pieces of
information.
Following completion of the procedure, the endoscope is returned to
the reprocessing center to put the instrument through HLD. During the
reprocessing activities, RFID-enabled touch-screen workstations record
the arrival of the endoscope and software automation from a touch-screen
monitor captures the completion of key HLD activities to ensure
compliance with organizational protocols. Upon completion of
reprocessing, the endoscopes are returned to the storage unit, thus
providing an automated, "closed loop" process for equipment utilization
and reprocessing. In addition, a full record is available to reflect the
completion of the HLD reprocessing activities to ensure all proper steps
have been completed to make it appropriate for subsequent use.
If a particular endoscope does not complete the cycle and in effect
"goes missing," the appropriate supervisors are automatically notified
so they can intervene. This ensures adherence to appropriate guidelines,
procedures and protocols. And it closes the security gap to reduce
theft.
This combination of storage equipment, RFID technology and software
automation can reduce the burden of managing endoscope equipment outside
the four walls of the procedure room. In turn, care providers can
mitigate the risks presented with utilization of this equipment and
benefit financially, clinically, and operationally by improving the
storage, management and reprocessing of these valuable tools.
Bryan Christianson is vice president, sales & marketing, Mobile
Aspects Inc.
|
30 tips
for decluttering, reorganizing storage space
Just like on those
popular cable television shows – or even "Oprah," let’s say a hospital
clinician or materials manager shows you photos of their storerooms
cluttered from the floor to the ceiling with supplies and equipment and
only narrow, meandering walkways for access. Healthcare Purchasing News
asked several storage system manufacturer executives what advice they
would give them.
1. Capturing
functionality, efficiency and productivity should be the top priorities
in the process of defining a High-Density Storage system. A thorough,
systematic analysis of each department is required, which will provide a
blueprint of the High-Density Storage system that will deliver these
benefits.
2. Choose a company
that offers both the storage products needed and layout design services
in-house rather than companies that specialize in only one or the other.
Companies that offer both streamline the reorganization process and
eliminate the potential of implementing a new design layout that is
unable to accommodate the storage products ordered.
3. Every department,
and in many cases, specific floors within a facility, have their own
specific storage needs. Avoid choosing a ‘one design fits all’ storage
system because it seems like the most cost-effective choice. In the long
run, this choice often accounts for the frustrating and challenging
clutter that occurs when departments try to fit themselves to the
existing system rather than the system serving the purpose of the
department. When the individual needs are accounted for and integrated
into the design of the storage systems, the goals of a highly organized,
effective supply chain will be achieved.
4. Clearly the
challenge is to identify a partner/supplier who is skilled in providing
these services along with the ability to customize High-Density Storage
systems for each defined use. Therefore, always research the companies
under consideration to find the best fit for the storage issues at hand.
5. Plan with the future
in mind. It is important to monitor, communicate and work in concert
with your supplier regarding the on-going changes and future plans for
facility growth. This will ensure the continuation of efficient storage
systems for years to come.
— John
Waner, CEO, IRSG
1. First and foremost –
make sure all the supplies are still current requirements. It’s amazing
how much inventory is still being stocked ‘because a particular
physician asked for it a couple of years ago, and we just still have
it.’ Determine realistic PAR levels.
2. Ascertain if the
current rate of procedures is expected to increase. Is there anticipated
growth with added physicians or procedures that needs to be addressed in
the storage plan?
3. Determine the
workflow and how personnel need to access the supplies.
4. Determine what needs
to be stocked as a specific procedure cart that can be moved as needed,
and whether mobile or stationary storage is preferable for other
supplies.
5. Utilizing all of the
above information, the photos of the current situation, packaging
measurements, room dimensions, we would then work up a plan to fit the
specified needs.
6. A comprehensive
proposal would be submitted to the customer with CAD drawings of the
room layout, as well as a CAD drawing of each individual storage unit
labeled as to the specific supplies to be stored therein. We would then
go over it with the customer to fine-tune the plan. If the proposal has
been well thought-out and prepared, it becomes easy for the customer to
visualize the end result.
—
Patricia List, executive vice president,
Medical Design Systems
1. The first thing we
would do is recommend our specialty, high-density storage products that
significantly reduce the amount of wasted cubic space. Most supplies in
these areas are stored in plastic bins on flat shelves. The shelf is
typically deeper than the bin, which is wasted shelf space. The space
between shelves is typically more than the height of the bin, which is
also wasted space.
2. Many facilities keep
items in pull-out bins or trays that make it difficult to keep track of
inventory. This can cause increased labor time to do the assessment of
inventory because every drawer has to be pulled out to see what is
inside. Nurses may not always have the time to pull out drawers, which
means they won’t have confidence that some of the items they need will
always be where they need it when they need it. This can cause them to
‘hoard,’ or keep supplies in several locations within a department where
they know they can get what they need. Our Par Wall system eliminates
this. Since there are no pull-out totes, every item is completely
visible when standing in front of the system. This significantly reduces
time needed for assessment and allows the nurses to know exactly where a
supply item is at all times.
3. Almost all of the
major healthcare distributors offer some kind of par level optimization
consulting. They will analyze purchases over the course of several
months and see if a facility is keeping the right amount of any given
supply in any given supply area based on their usage and ordering. This
can help enormously in streamlining supplies and eliminate wasted or
unused inventory.
— Nick
Klusty, vice president, Western region,
Logiquip LLC
Organization and
decluttering can be effective or quite damaging depending on the rigor
of the approach. Lowering inventory levels haphazardly, removing product
based on perceptions of non-utilization and moving product locations can
all have negative effects on the patient care process if such changes
are not approached with analytical care. In addition, organization
without process change inevitably tends back towards chaos. To lock in
such gains, the underlying causes of the problem must first be
addressed. Our suggestions would be:
1. Harmonization of the
MMIS item master with physical inventory to create a clear information
platform from which to drive change.
2. Implementation of
supply automation technology to generate accurate utilization
information to enable effective inventory analysis.
3. Utilization of
supply automation technology to enable clinical and supply chain users
to identify product locations quickly and effectively.
4. Inventory
right-sizing based on actual product utilization – using information to
reduce inventory levels without creating stockouts.
5. SKU reduction by
weeding out unused product and standardizing redundant product lines on
single functional equivalents.
—
Scott Bostick, vice president and general manager,
Pyxis Supply Technologies, Cardinal Health Inc.
Storeroom redesign has
three major components to it: Critical thinking, workflow and hardware.
1. Critical thinking: A
store room that is cluttered from floor to ceiling is an indication that
the hospital needs to determine if the items stocked in that location
truly need to be there. The first step in the decision tree is to
complete a physical inventory to be sure that the Master Item File for
that location accurately reflects what is there.
2. Utilization history
should be reviewed to identify ordering patterns of the supplies.
Anything that has not moved in six months should be designated a ‘No
Move’ item. No Move items should be considered as an item that can be
eliminated from the hospital totally or moved to a direct spend category
and managed by the particular department.
3. Workflow:
Utilization history also allows the hospital to categorize supplies in
terms of velocity of movement, designating items by A, B, or C priority.
The hospital should also classify the supplies by clinical categories
such as Respiratory, IV, Patient Care, Wound Care, etc. Color coding of
bins or labels should follow these classifications to provide rapid
visual location support.
4. Finally the supplies
should be situated ergonomically with ‘A’ items at waist height and
centrally located in the room. ‘B’ items in close proximity, ‘C’ items
lower on the racks and at locations farther from the entrance point.
5. Hardware: There are
a variety of storage systems available on the market. The hospital
should consider gravity feed shelves for IV solutions and expiring,
bulky items, Par Walls to optimize available wall space and reduce
cleaning cycles of plastic bins. High density rolling racks can deliver
the needed cube space in cramped rooms that don’t allow for walkways or
aisles. Automated supply towers deliver both storage space and
electronic procurement functions.
6. The hospital should
engage a logistics expert from their prime vendor to assist in designing
a supply chain model that includes the hospitals vision for materials
managements, room layout and work flow specifications.
— Dan
Pfister, director, technical sales,
Cardinal Health Inc.
1. Using data collected
from a point-of-use system, eliminate the 20-percent-to-30- percent of
items that are never or rarely used.
2. Using data collected
from a point-of-use system, reduce the quantity of the remaining items
to proper levels based on usage/costs calculations, and space
constraints. Balance inventory costs with distribution costs.
3. Use a cost effective
bin system affixed to louvers on the wall. Maintain one item per bin.
Affix clear labels in a standard and professional manner, utilizing
caregiver terminology.
4. Using data collected
from a point-of-use system, place your top usage items closest to the
entrance to the PAR Location in order to reduce caregivers efforts. Sort
the remainder by item type with the assistance of the caregivers.
5. Develop processes
and controls to assure that the PAR location is maintained as it was
originally set-up.
— Joe
Dattilo, president,
PAR Excellence Systems Inc. |
|