The benefits of lean storage in CSPD
by Chris Govero
T
he Perioperative Services south campus supply
room at Barnes-Jewish Hospital (BJH) in St. Louis, MO, services 38 operating
rooms which collectively perform approximately 80 surgeries per day.
The 27,000-sq. ft. supply room houses the Central Sterile and Processing
Department (CSPD) and the Materials Management Department (MM). The south
campus CSPD processes 500 trays per day, builds 85-100 case carts, and
processes over 500,000 instruments per month. The MM department contains
1,300 unique surgical supplies and manages an $800,000 inventory; 108
Omnicells; and 21,437 supply locations.
The LEAN methodology was utilized in the supply room to transform how
supplies and instruments were managed and the case cart picking process.
Prior to the event, BJC HealthCare (parent organization of BJH) staff
performed daily counts on 2,300 SKUs ($2.1 million of inventory) for the
ordering process. This task took six hours to complete. The original layout
of the supply room was also not ergonomically correct and staff had to walk
more than 800 ft. to build a single case cart. The extensive walking and
poor ergonomics within the environment caused on-the-job injuries and
additional stress to the staff. The original layout was also not conducive
for efficient case cart building and did not allow for the development of a
just-in-time process for case cart building. LEAN methodology was identified
as the best opportunity to help deal with these issues and provide a more
visual, manageable, cost effective, and efficient storeroom.
|
 |
|
MGI board |
|
 |
|
Replenishment board |
Establishing our goals
Ten goals were established to ensure delivery of the correct supplies and
instruments to the surgical team in the operating rooms:
1. Manageable LEAN 5S process (sort, straighten, shine, standardize,
sustain)
2. Defect metric of 97% (3 sigma) – Defects for supplies were identified
as overstocked, stocked-out, in the wrong location, or mislabeled. Defects
for instruments were identified as tray mislabeled, shelf mislabeled, tray
in the wrong location, or the lock was broken on the tray.
3. Reduce supply stock-outs from 200 to 0 (100%)
4. Eliminate overstock
5. Eliminate case cart supply outages
6. Reduce case cart picking time by 25%
7. Implement a Kanban system to help reduce the time it took to order
supplies by 80%
8. Provide an ergonomically correct working environment
9. Reduce walking distance to build a case cart by 25%
10. Develop standard work for case cart building
Goals to reality
To make these goals a reality, the team conducted a Lean 2P (process and
preparation) event that helped redesign the storeroom from scratch. Three
separate sections were identified: supplies, custom packs, and instruments.
Following the 2P event, it took several months of planning and preparation
and two separate rapid improvement events (RIEs) to reorganize the supplies
and implement a Kanban type of just-in-time pull system.
After these two RIEs, the instruments were reorganized. While
reorganizing the supplies and instruments, the team also right-sized all
locations and ensured all supplies and instruments had a clearly identified
"home". This would ensure that improvements were sustained and no
overstocked instruments or supplies could be misplaced.
The major initiative during the instrument reorganization was to set up
the area in a proper ergonomic fashion. Following the instrument
reorganization, packs were dealt with. The team identified an opportunity to
reduce the packs safety stock inventory from 430 packs to 150 packs, with 90
packs arriving daily for the following day’s use.
The final event took into consideration how staff does their work. In the
original state, a staff member would build a single case cart (supplies,
instruments, and packs) from start to finish. In the new state, staff was
trained to build case carts in a flow cell. In a flow cell case cart picking
with single piece flow, items are picked-and-passed to the next flow cell to
level the work load, decrease walking, and increase efficiency.
With a Kanban system and the new storeroom layout in place, the flow of
work has greatly improved and employees are much more effective. The reorder
process has been reduced from 6 hours to 0.5 hours and eliminated counting.
The 5S score went from a 1.1 to a 4.8 in the supply area and from a 1.0 to
3.8 in the instrument area. The yield percentage increased from 67% to 97%.
The distance it took to build a single case cart was reduced from 864 ft.
to less than 200 ft. The time it took to build one case cart decreased from
8 minutes to less than 4 minutes. To address the ergonomic situation, the
NIOSH Lift Index was used to help determine how ergonomically friendly our
environment was. The NIOSH Lift Index decreased (lower the number the less
strain on the body) from a score of 1.66 (from wire rack) and 1.75 (to case
cart) to 1.53 (from wire rack) and 1.41 (to case cart)
|
Table 1 |
|
Metrics |
Old State (9-8-08) |
Current State
(7-23-09) |
|
Safety/5S |
|
5S Score for Supplies |
1.1 |
4.8 |
|
5S Score for Instruments |
1.0 |
3.8 |
|
NIOSH Lift Index |
1.66 (wire rack)
1.75 (case cart) |
1.53 (wire rack)
1.41 (case cart) |
|
Walking Distance (ft) |
864 |
<200 |
|
Quality |
|
Yield Rate |
67% |
97% |
|
Supply Stock-outs (lines/day) |
200 |
7 |
|
Delivery |
|
Case Cart Supply Outages
(% of case carts affected) |
50% |
0 |
|
Time to Build Case Cart (mins.) |
8:00 |
<4:00 |
|
Case Cart Building Start Time |
23:00 |
23:00 |
|
Case Cart Building End Time |
10:00 |
05:00 |
|
Supply Ordering Time (hours) |
6.0 |
0.5 |
|
Cost |
|
Overstock Value |
$600,000 |
$1,000 |
Christopher L. Govero is a Performance Improvement Engineer at
Barnes-Jewish Hospital in St. Louis, MO.
