ankenau Hospital in Wynnewood,
Pennsylvania is an acute-care, non-
profit teaching and research-based hospital recognized for its clinical
excellence and commitment to patient care. In 2009, it was named one of
America’s 50 Best Hospitals by HealthGrades, placing it in the top 1 percent
of all hospitals in the nation for quality outcomes.
John H. Marks, M.D., FACS, FASCRS, Chief of Colorectal
Surgery and Director of the Fellowship in Minimally Invasive Colorectal
Surgery and Rectal Cancer Management at Lankenau Hospital, is an expert in
and an advocate of minimally invasive colorectal surgical techniques. He has
performed over 950 laparoscopic colorectal surgeries during the course of
his career.
Dr. Marks had been using a disposable Babcock grasper to
handle tissue during these procedures but was concerned about the device’s
clinical efficacy since the grasper tip was unsuitable for handling delicate
bowel tissue. According to Marks, if the grasper tip is too small or too
sharp, it can tear the tissue and lead to serious post-operative
complications. In the case of bowel surgery, tissue perforations can allow
fecal matter to leak into the abdomen, putting the patient at risk for
sepsis.
"Tissue handling is crucial for colorectal surgery since you
have to manipulate and move various organs during the procedures. There’s a
lot of opportunity to inflict tissue damage if you’re using poor quality
instrumentation," said Dr. Marks.
In addition, the plastic handles on disposable devices were
uncomfortable to manipulate. As a result, Dr. Marks experienced numbness in
his fingers during long, complicated cases. Since he frequently performs two
or three cases each day, it became a significant issue.
"It was so severe that I was concerned that I would no
longer be able to perform these procedures," said Dr. Marks.
The high cost of the disposable device was a concern as
well. A typical hospital performs an average of 2,000 laparoscopic
procedures each year and during each procedure, the surgeon uses
approximately three different instruments, including graspers, dissectors
and scissors. Since disposable devices can cost $90 or more, a typical
hospital spends approximately $540,000 annually on such instruments and
$180,000 on this single device alone.
"The fact that we had to throw out the device after a single
use increased the cost of each case," said Dr. Marks. "I wanted to find
something more economical for the hospital."
Quality, comfort and economy
 |
|
John H. Marks, M.D., FACS, FASCRS |
For 10 years, Dr. Marks searched for a solution but no
single instrument met all of his needs. That changed in 2005 when he led a
laparoscopic colorectal surgery training course at the Society of American
Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES) Annual Meeting. During the
course, he had the opportunity to use a variety of surgical instrumentation,
including Microline Surgical’s reposable laparoscopic surgical system.
"It was immediately apparent to me that this was the
solution that I had been searching for all of those years," said Dr. Marks.
"The device felt great in my hands, it handled tissue well and it was cost
effective to the hospital, a real trifecta."
The Microline Surgical system that Dr. Marks used is
comprised of the ReNew universal reusable hand piece and a wide variety of
disposable tips for tissue cutting, grasping and dissecting. This reposable
system offers the clinical and economic benefits of a disposable instrument
combined with the quality and precision of a fully reusable instrument. The
scissor tips are changed after every case to ensure that the surgeon always
has a sharp cutting edge while the grasper and dissector tips can be used
many times before they must be discarded, providing a significant cost
savings over single-use devices.
Shortly thereafter, Dr. Marks began using Microline
Surgical’s reposable system in his practice. Because of its intuitive,
integrated design, there is minimal training involved. The system features
coaxial threading for easy assembly, which is unique to the industry. Since
there are two sets of interlocking threads, the tip cannot detach from the
handle during surgery. This patented design provides added safety.
"I’ve performed many laparoscopic surgeries during my career
so I have a rule that if you place an instrument into my hand and I can’t
figure out how to use it in a couple of minutes, then there must be a design
flaw," said Dr. Marks. "Because Microline Surgical’s instruments are so
intuitively simple, I needed no training at all."

The quality and versatility of Microline Surgical’s system
addresses Dr. Marks’ efficacy concerns as well. The company offers a wide
variety of precision graspers in different sizes and widths, enabling Dr.
Marks to choose a tip that best meets his needs. For example, Microline
Surgical’s Super Atrau Graspers are single use tips with a soft padded
grasper designed to protect sensitive tissue like the bowel.
"In the past, I had a very difficult time finding a grasper
paddle for handling delicate bowel tissue," said Dr. Marks. "The paddle on
Microline Surgical’s 5 mm grasper is excellent for holding the bowel since
it is wide enough to spread the force over a greater area and prevent
tearing."
In addition, the system is ergonomically designed to provide
a more substantial and responsive tactile experience compared to disposable
plastic handles. It features removable, reusable ring inserts for a custom
fit, which addresses the comfort issues that Dr. Marks had been experiencing
with the disposable device.
"The numbness is completely gone," said Dr. Marks. "When I
now use instruments that don’t have the handle rings, it feels so foreign to
me – like the difference between sitting on a non-cushioned versus a
cushioned seat."
To date, Dr. Marks has performed over 400 laparoscopic
colorectal procedures with Microline Surgical’s reposable system, including
rectal cancer surgery, right/left colectomies and total proctocolectomies.
It has provided a significant cost savings to the hospital over single-use
devices.
|
At a Glance
Lankenau Hospital •
Wynnewood, Pennsylvania
Application: Tissue grasping and handling
during laparoscopic colorectal surgery
System: ReNew Universal Handpiece and
ControlTip Graspers, Microline
Benefits: • High quality and versatility
minimize risk of tissue damage and improve clinical outcomes
• Ergonomic design is comfortable and easy to
use
• Offers significant cost savings over
disposable devices
• Eco-friendly design reduces medical waste and
associated costs |
|
Since Microline Surgical’s hand piece is reusable and its
grasper tips can be reused for multiple cases, the cost to the hospital is
just a few dollars per procedure, compared with $90 per procedure for a
single use device. If a hospital, such as Lankenau, replaced just one single
disposable instrument with one of Microline Surgical’s devices, it could
save well over $180,000 annually and that hard cost savings could be well
over half a million dollars if it replaced all three disposable instruments
– graspers, scissors and dissectors – with reposable devices.
Lastly, in the midst of the current economic crisis as the
U.S. focuses its sights on healthcare reform, "going green" can be an
effective way for hospitals to both reduce waste and cut hard and soft
costs. The eco-friendly design of Microline Surgical’s reposable instruments
enable hospitals to achieve this goal since they require less shelf space,
feature less packaging materials and generate less waste compared to fully
disposable devices.
In closing, Dr. Marks states, "In my opinion, these
instruments are great because they have solved all of my issues – safety,
comfort and cost – in one fell swoop."