Tarnished silver…bullet?
Languishing in the summer heat (as those wilting Toyota execs must or
should be) may not seem desirable right now, but here’s a vignette to cool
your feathers and teach you a thing or two.
One corporate source sent me the following e-mail message back during
the throes and floes of winter that explicitly illustrates dependability,
reliability and high-quality customer service.
"The view from [edited]’s conference room includes a train station and
a steakhouse. There’s about 24 inches of snow on the ground, and the
forecast calls for it to continue falling for another 12+ hours. Trains
are not running, schools are closed, most businesses are closed, mail has
not arrived, FedEx has not arrived, UPS has not arrived…
BUT, the Coors truck just delivered to the steakhouse!"
Surely, those high-priced efficiency management consultants must be
salivating at the underlying message – ignoring the beer reference, of
course. After all, Coors demonstrated it operates a lean, mean
distribution machine. Just don’t passively dismiss the example because
Coors hails from a state accustomed to blankets of cold white powder.
Toyota, believe it or not, as well any other professional weaned on
lean management, could learn a lesson from the Colorado brewer.
Unfortunately, Toyota’s recall activities, nefarious or negligent, may
cast a pall on the reputation of the lean management system it so
dutifully and endearingly exercised and promoted for decades. That’s truly
tragic but also misguided and misplaced.
Lean management principles should be blight-free and not infected by
the miscues and mistakes of its prominent corporate purveyor.
Delayed recall procedures, debunking strategies and plans to discredit
witnesses are not outgrowths of lean management evangelism. They are
symptoms of the most popular evangelist’s panic at having been caught
cutting corners, curtailing quality and covering its behind – all
deviations from the effective management program the evangelist long
espoused.
Healthcare Purchasing News readers are too intelligent and
observant to allow Toyota’s predicament to besmirch the lean management
principles they have been, are, or may very well be implementing at their
facilities to improve operations.
Efficiencies don’t emanate from errors and vice versa.
As we’ve witnessed before and after Toyota’s revelations the successful
Japanese automaker doesn’t suffer alone from quality management troubles.
Quite a few of its domestic and international competitors have struggled
to clean their own houses with more than a socket wrench and a Quicken
app.
But the lesson remains steadfast. The messenger may ring hollow but the
message still can ring true, akin to a twist on the old "Chicken Little"
fable.
Whether the economy and/or your organization’s budget can be classified
as lean, the management initiative that may make positive waves continues
to be lean.
Take that to the bank…in a silver Toyota should you choose. Just don’t
drink and drive even if all this chaos may drive you to drink.