Operating room fires have
occurred for decades. Recent reports in the medical literature suggest
that the risk for surgical fires may be increasing due to more prevalent
use of surgical lasers, electrocautery units, fiberoptic light sources
and disposable drapes.1,2 The ECRI (formerly known as the Emergency Care
Research Institute), an independent non-profit health research agency,
estimates that approximately 100 surgical fires occur each year, causing
20 serious injuries and one or two deaths.3 Nearly all of these fires
ignite on or within the patient.4 Fires that occur elsewhere,
such as on linens or other materials within the operating room, may not
be reported, although many states have legal requirements to report any
fire, and organizations such as the Joint Commission on Accreditation of
Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) require fire documentation as part of
hospital accreditation standards.3 This article examines the role of
surgical product selection as it relates to fire risk.
Fire components: An overview
The three components necessary to start a fire—an ignition source,
oxygen and fuel—are referred to as the "fire triangle" and have been
widely discussed in clinical guidelines and in the medical
literature.2,4,5
Ignition:
The list of devices in the operating room that produce enough heat
to ignite a fire is extensive (see Heat Sources).The tips of
electrocautery units can reach several hundred degrees, and lasers focus
intense heat into a small area and can ignite nearly any material in its
path.2 Other devices can produce sparks.4 Depending on the heat source,
combustion may occur after several minutes or even within a few seconds
of exposure to a fuel source. Operating room staff must ensure that heat
sources are not directed toward fuel.4,5
Oxygen:
Oxygen is found within the air in the operating room and from external
sources, such as the anesthesia machine, ventilator and from oxygen
canisters. An oxygen-rich environment increases the risk that combustion
will occur when heat comes into contact with fuel.4
Fuel:
Fuel includes nearly anything. Obvious fuel sources consist of items
that are known to be flammable, such as skin prepping agents, linens and
paper products. But a heat source that is hot enough, especially in an
oxygen-rich environment, will also ignite items that generally are not
considered flammable, such as petroleum-based ointments, tubing and
equipment casings.4
Reducing fire risk
Education of the operating room staff is critical to reducing the risk
of fire and, importantly, providing swift, effective procedures for
extinguishing fires that do occur. Several guidelines include extensive
information about every aspect of controlling the fire triangle;
essentially, if one of the three elements of the triangle is controlled,
fire risk is reduced.2,4,5
Some of the components
that contribute to fire risk are easier to control than others, however.
For example, while proper handling of a laser device is of paramount
importance, the device cannot be eliminated entirely, despite its
potential risk as a source of ignition. The same is true of oxygen
supplied with anesthesia or through a ventilator. Staff should evaluate
the need for 100 percent oxygen, depending on the procedure.5
The component that allows
the most choice in fire control is the fuel source. Although some fuel
sources are found on or within the patient, such as body hair and gases,
the operating room is stocked with abundant fuel sources largely
necessary for infection control. These include:
• Antiseptic skin
preparation agents
• Linens such as drapes,
gowns, masks, caps, shoe covers and bedding
• Dressing materials and
sponges
• Ointments
• Gloves
This is not an exhaustive
list of fuels, of course, but infection control supplies may provide
more choice than other components in terms of the range of products that
can be purchased and the manner in which they are used. For example,
ECRI guidelines include instructions for antiseptic skin preparation and
materials handling that can minimize fire risks:4
• Do not allow flammable
liquid preps to pool on the patient’s skin or in open containers
• Skin preps should be
completely dry before the patient is draped; excess solution can be
wicked into the draping
• Use a properly applied
incise drape to isolate head and neck incisions from an oxygen-enriched
atmosphere and flammable vapors trapped beneath drapes and to eliminate
a channel for gas to escape into the surgical site
• Coat facial hair
(including eyebrows, beard and mustache) near the surgical site with
water-based surgical lubricating jelly, which is nonflammable
• Ensure that alcohol
vapors have dissipated before allowing a heat source in proximity
• Be aware of the
flammability of prepping agents and dressings during surgery
Based on these
guidelines, some assumptions can be made: the type of applicator for
antiseptic skin preparations is an important criterion for product
selection, and water-based ointments are safer choices than petrolatum.
The need to control the
application of flammable solutions during electrocautery procedures
cannot be overstated. The Food and Drug Administration requires that
solutions with alcohol must have an applicator that controls solution
flow, allows alcohol vapors to dissipate and minimizes excess solution
from collecting—single-use bottles with no applicators should not be
used.
In addition to carefully
evaluating flammable solutions, purchasers may wish to re-evaluate the
use of disposable drapes. These materials are less expensive than cloth
drapes but are much more flammable, even when treated with flame
retardants.2
Conclusion
Preventing surgical fires requires attention from everyone in the
operating room as well as hospital staff members who are responsible for
researching and making purchasing decisions. The potential for surgical
fire risk is another consideration in the process of selecting products.
There may be more choice in evaluating infection control products, such
as antiseptic skin preparations and draping materials, than there is in
other components of the fire triangle. Understanding how a product
should be used to minimize fire risk—such as the need to control the
flow of a flammable solutions—is part of the product selection process.
HPN