New blood test offers cancer detection and cost-effective procedure

Jan. 13, 2023

Researchers are reporting progress on a blood test that can detect multiple cancers in a relatively simpler, and potentially less pricey way than other tests under development. The test picks up certain cancer signals in the blood using a fairly straightforward method: counting bits of DNA that appear to be "broken" in unexpected places.

In the new study, scientists found that the approach can distinguish people with any of 11 different types of cancer from people who are cancer-free. Not only that, it can do so using a relatively small blood sample, according to senior researcher Dr. Muhammed Murtaza, of the University of Wisconsin's School of Medicine and Public Health, in Madison. 

"The biggest advantage of our approach would probably be in cost-effectiveness," Murtaza said, although he added that it's hard to make predictions on real-world costs. 

The study, published Jan. 11 in the journal Science Translational Medicine, is among the latest in the broader push to develop blood tests that can serve as a one-stop screening for multiple cancers. 

A number of companies are working on such "multi-cancer" early detection tests. Essentially, they are all based on the fact that tumors shed bits of genetic material in the blood. If a test can detect those tumor signals, that could provide a simple, noninvasive way to screen for various cancers, including ones that now lack any screening method. 

Where the tests vary is in what, exactly, they are measuring, Murtaza explained. He and his colleagues took the approach of analyzing DNA "fragmentation patterns." Both tumor cells and healthy cells regularly release pieces of DNA into the blood. But because tumors express different genes than normal body cells do, they also differ in how those DNA bits break off. 

The new test looks at the "end position" of DNA fragments in the blood, to see if the breaks happened in "unexpected places," Murtaza said. He described it as a "simple method" that allows for a smaller blood sample containing a limited supply of DNA (which, in the world of DNA, amounts to a minimum of 1 million fragments). 

For the study, the researchers analyzed blood samples from 286 healthy people, 103 who had non-cancer medical conditions, and 994 people with one of 11 types of cancer. They ranged from breast and ovarian cancers to melanoma, to rarer cancers like bile duct tumors, and the deadly brain cancer, glioblastoma. 

Overall, the researchers found, the test did a good job of pinpointing which blood samples came from cancer patients, including those who had early-stage cancer, which is important in a screening test. The test had an "area-under-curve" (AUC) of 0.91 for cancer overall, and 0.87 for stage 1 cancer, according to the researchers. The AUC is a measure of test accuracy that ranges from 0 to 1: the closer it is to 1, the better. 

More research is still needed, according to Murtaza. One of the next steps, he said, is to see how well the test performs in detecting a single cancer, rather than multiple ones—including pancreatic cancer, a deadly disease for which there is no screening test. 

MedicalXpress release

Photo 79060266 © Susanne Neal | Dreamstime.com
Photo 37021977 © Anton Starikov | Dreamstime.com
37129089 © Tyler Olson, 26709588 © Dmitry Kalinovsky | Dreamstime.com
204557142 © Andrei Malov | Dreamstime.com