Two Studies Show Shortcomings and Promise of AI Tools to Detect Lung Cancer

Generally, these AI tools were successful in prompting radiologists to double-check an x-ray, but struggled to identify nodules themselves.

Key Highlights

  • A retrospective study compared AI findings with radiologists’ reports on more than 25,000 X-rays taken from October 2025 to February 2026.
  • When reports disagreed, researchers followed up with patients; AI was useful for prompting radiologists to double-check X-rays.
  • The X-ray study found AI was less adept at identifying nodules on its own.
  • A separate CT study found an AI model’s performance declined when applied to more than 10,000 patients.
  • Researchers said performance may vary depending on training data and the clinical setting, such as outpatient or emergency radiology.

Recent studies examining the use of AI tools in lung cancer and radiology found that different tools garnered mixed results.

One study involved a retrospective analysis of over 25,000 x-rays taken between October 2025 and February 2026. Each x-ray was first reviewed by academic professionals and then by AI. The research team then compared the radiologists' reports with AI findings. They followed up with the patient if there was a discrepancy between the two reports.

The study showed that AI was good at prompting radiologists to double-check an x-ray, but it was less adept at identifying nodules on its own.

Another study analyzed the results of an AI tool that performed successfully in a lab setting and used in clinics to spot pulmonary nodules in CT scans. Bruno Hochhegger, the study team's leader, said that "the performance of this AI model decreased a lot" when applied to more than 10,000 patients.

Part of this is down to what data the AI was trained on. Additionally, if you train a tool for an outpatient center, for instance, it might work differently than a tool trained on emergency radiology patients.

About the Author

Matt MacKenzie

Matt MacKenzie

Associate Editor

Matt MacKenzie is Senior Staff Writer and Associate Editor of Healthcare Purchasing News (HPN), where he leads daily news coverage and contributes in-depth features on healthcare supply chain, sterile processing, infection prevention and clinical operations. Through industry reporting and expert interviews, he examines the trends, technologies and operational challenges shaping healthcare purchasing and patient care. 

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates